Opening the door on Martin Scorsese’s ‘The Irishman’
By DAVID A. KING, Ph.D. | Published November 9, 2026
My father was fascinated by unsolved mysteries, and three obsessed him: Who was responsible for the assassination of President John F. Kennedy? Who was the Watergate informant Deep Throat? Who killed Jimmy Hoffa, and where did they put his body?
We may never know the full truth about the Kennedy assassination, though if you believe the findings of the Warren Commission, there is no mystery.
We do know the identity of Deep Throat, who was revealed in 2005 to be former FBI agent Mark Felt. My father found the Felt revelation as “The Secret Man” to be anticlimactic, as it is now known that President Nixon knew his identity even during the initial Washington Post investigative reporting. It was more fun to imagine who Deep Throat might have been than to know the truth.
As for the disappearance of Hoffa, now that’s a puzzle that may never be solved. Of all the theories and claims that have been made, the most striking is the story told by Mafia associate Frank Sheeran that forms the basis of Charles Brandt’s 2004 book “I Heard You Paint Houses,” which was the inspiration for Martin Scorsese’s brilliant 2019 film “The Irishman.”
Sheeran claimed that in addition to shooting Hoffa and burning his body in an incinerator, he had been responsible for more than 25 other mob hits. In reality, Sheeran may have not killed anyone. A notorious liar, Sheeran valued attention and recognition more than truth. Even author Brandt cannot confirm if Sheeran really told the truth.
Hoffa joined the Teamsters Union in 1933 and served as its president from 1957-1971. He was a charismatic though controversial leader who was frequently at odds with Attorney General Robert Kennedy. He served a prison sentence from 1967-1971 until Nixon commuted his sentence provided he stay out of union activities.
Sheeran and Hoffa had a deep professional and personal relationship. It would have been as easy for Sheeran to hurt Hoffa as it was for Brutus and Cassius to slay Caesar. Sheeran’s account is matter of fact: he claimed to have shot Hoffa twice in the head in a Detroit house and then burned his body.
Wild conjecture over the decades has famously placed Hoffa’s remains in locations as outlandish as under Giants Stadium, but what is known is simple. On July 30, 1975, Hoffa was seen in the parking lot of the Machus Red Fox restaurant in suburban Detroit where he had arrived for a meeting with mob leaders who never arrived. He has never been seen again, and his body has never been found. A federal judge declared him legally dead exactly seven years later. Yet the FBI case on the Hoffa disappearance is still an open investigation.
Sheeran’s confession was almost immediately renounced by the FBI as “lacking all credibility.” Forensics and alibis don’t support Sheeran’s story, and Sheeran himself told outlandish tales about what had happened to the body. Like other unsolved mysteries such as the D.B. Cooper, Amelia Earhart, and Bigfoot cases, we will probably never know what really happened to Jimmy Hoffa.
Conspiracy theorists and true crime fans may quibble with the version presented by Scorsese in “The Irishman,” but Scorsese never meant to make a documentary. The movie is less about what might have happened to Jimmy Hoffa, and more concerned with the state of a man’s soul.
Connecting faith and imagination
If I could meet any living Catholic artist, it would be Martin Scorsese. Beyond his astonishing filmography, Scorsese has done so much for film history and preservation, and he has defended the connection between faith and imagination. It’s easy to see in his films the perspective that almost led him to priesthood in his youth. From “Taxi Driver” through “The Departed” to his television series on the saints, Scorsese has exemplified his statement that “The Catholic Church has never left me, and I have never left it.”
Scorsese has always worked with several important collaborators, all of whom are among the greatest actors in American film history. Robert De Niro especially has been crucial. “The Irishman” was in development for years after Scorsese read Brandt’s book. De Niro was in from the beginning, along with other notables such as Joe Pesci, Al Pacino and Harvey Keitel.

Award-winning filmmaker Martin Scorsese has long defended the connection between faith and imagination. OSV News/Fox Nation
The film became the longest Scorsese has ever made, at nearly three and a half hours, and most audiences first encountered it either on Netflix or Criterion. Advanced CGI techniques and special effects were used to portray the primary actors across decades of youth, middle age and near death. The film never seems long, and rewards viewing either in segments or in one sitting. Many critics—even my son—describe the film as “flowing.”
The first two hours of the film can be brutal and cold, a hard reminder of Flannery O’Connor’s assertion that “for the hard of hearing you shout and for the almost blind you draw large and startling figures.” Frank’s hits are swift and sure, almost breathtaking. Scorsese imposes on screen epitaphs for all the slain gangsters, which renders them for a moment not simply as killings or “painted houses,” but real people.
The movie’s final hour is different. In the last third of the film, a quiet reflective power takes over the violent action of the first two parts. Daylight sequences, shot in a cold, grey midwestern light, replace the film’s early nighttime and interior scenes. The mundane processes of the justice system, Frank’s resigned selection of a casket and crypt, and the monotony of prison and a nursing home are all compelling because they too deal explicitly with life and death. In the earlier part of the film, death is instant and unexpected. In the final third, death is a quiet yet felt presence. In prison, Frank’s dying friend Russell Bufalino goes to church. Frank seems surprised, but Russell says knowingly, “You’ll see.”
As the film nears its conclusion, all the old gangsters are dead. Only Frank remains. The FBI pleads with Frank to reveal what he knows, but he holds fast to the Omerta code and refuses to tell law enforcement anything. But he does tell a priest, and this device is what makes the film a masterwork.
The film opens with an elderly Frank in a nursing home talking, addressing someone we don’t know. It might be a nurse; it might be the priest we see in the hallway, or it might be us the audience. The device is one commonly used by Edgar Allan Poe and Alfred Hitchcock, and it implicates the audience even as it establishes an aura of mystery or uncertainty. Frank explains how he became involved in organized crime, and how he came to be on the journey that ended in Hoffa’s death. The film then winds through multiple flashbacks until we arrive back at the nursing home where Frank is talking to a priest, a conversation that is at last revealed to be a sacramental confession.
The last three people we see Frank talking to are the priest—who is brilliantly played by Jonathan Morris—an assisted-living nurse and a casket salesman. Each assumes an archetypal presence. In one of the film’s most ironic and telling moments, Frank assumes that his young nurse will know the mystery of Jimmy Hoffa. Embarrassed, she admits that she has never even heard of Hoffa.
The priest must urge the confession out of Frank; he pleads for some sincere contrition or remorse. It is heartbreaking to watch how much he wants to save Frank’s soul. At last, he seems to be satisfied; the two pray together, and he grants absolution. Near Christmas, he returns to visit Frank, and the implication is that the two have developed a relationship.
At his last visit, as the priest prepares to leave, Frank asks him to leave the door slightly open. This is one of the most memorable and moving moments in the film. In Irish folklore, tradition dictates that in the room of a person near death, a window or door should be left slightly open or ajar for the soul to pass on unimpeded. The ending of the film is therefore not as ambiguous as we might think, for the open door suggests that Frank has hope his soul will go on.
“The Irishman” is best understood through a Catholic perspective. Perhaps only a Catholic can appreciate the urgency of the priest who encourages Frank’s hesitant confession. A Catholic knows the true meaning of that open door. A Catholic knows that Frank’s ruminations about the finality of the grave are in fact overruled by the priest who saves his soul and the priest who buries his body in the hope of resurrection.
Only a Catholic could have made this film. Scorsese doesn’t condemn Frank, who certainly deserves condemnation and punishment; instead, he ends his movie with a priest’s fervent belief in redemption and forgiveness and the quiet, abiding, tentative hope of the man who wants his door ajar, at last open to something better.
David A. King, Ph.D., is professor of English and film studies at Kennesaw State University and director of OCIA at Holy Spirit Church, Atlanta.