Georgia Bulletin

The Newspaper of the Catholic Archdiocese of Atlanta


Catholic advocates for immigrants assess how to win allies, combat fear

By ANDREW NELSON, Staff Writer | Published June 1, 2017  | En Español

ATLANTA—Frances McBrayer used to be able to focus on ensuring that refugees had an apartment to live in, the weary travelers were picked up at Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta International Airport and had jobs lined up to integrate families who had spent years in desolate camps into the Atlanta community.

Her work would accompany families of refugees fleeing oppression on their first steps in America.

Now the longtime Catholic Charities Atlanta staff member for the past few years has worked with a dozen coalition partners to be a public voice for these newcomers. Now the job includes organizing photo opportunities at the Georgia Statehouse where former refugees pose with politicians and state leaders to talk about how they contribute to the community.

“Advocacy has become a requirement for the environment we are in,” said McBrayer, who leads CCA’s refugee resettlement program and is the new chairwoman of the Coalition of Refugee Service Agencies, a 14-member Georgia organization.

“We have always really done the direct service work without talking about it too much,” she said. “A large part of what we are doing now is trying to demonstrate how much work is being done, how much refugees are contributing to our state (economically, socially and culturally), and how many people are involved in and supportive of the effort.”

Lawyers and advocates with the Catholic Legal Immigration Network Inc., known as CLINIC, talked at the nonprofit’s national convening in Atlanta about how their work has pivoted from behind the scenes, filing legal documents in court, to being a louder voice for immigrants in an unwelcoming political environment.

“Move beyond outrage”

Some 500 lawyers and advocates for immigrants met May 24 to 26 for the event under the theme “A Welcoming America for All.”

The conference took place in a changed national landscape. President Donald Trump since taking office in January has signed executive orders temporarily banning immigration from certain Muslim-majority countries and set stricter illegal immigration enforcement with a robust deportation policy. His travel restriction executive orders have been stopped by adverse court rulings to date.

U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement reported officers arrested between Jan. 22 and April 29 more than 41,000 individuals on alleged immigration violations. That is a nearly 38 percent increase in arrests made during the same period of the Obama administration in 2016.

“There is fear for the immigrant community,” said CLINIC Executive Director Jeanne Atkinson.

People are anxious, she said, but advocates are not deterred.

“By and large, they are mission-driven. The mission doesn’t change regardless of the administration, what’s happening in Congress. That level of focus keeps people going,” she said.

During two days of panel discussions and updates on immigration law, panelists acknowledged the need to make allies, sometimes with people who don’t always share the same point of view.

Bishop Kevin Vann, of the Diocese of Orange, California, chairman of CLINIC’s board of directors, said the election’s aftermath angered some who care about immigrant rights, but now is the time to roll up their sleeves and get to work.

“We have to move beyond outrage,” he said.

Instead, organize forums and discussions for unauthorized immigrants to help them make plans in case they are arrested, Bishop Vann said.

“You can stay in outrage, but you aren’t really helping anybody,” he said.

Find new allies

A workshop focused on building coalitions within the Catholic community and with other groups drew some two-dozen people.

Allies can be people who don’t share the same religious beliefs but the same values, panelists said. Others talked about setting up meetings with federal immigration officials to learn more about them and mend fences.

Sister Mary Ellen Burns told of a parish near New Haven, Connecticut, St. Rose of Lima Church, where people from other faiths surround the church when Hispanic Catholics worship to watch for federal immigration officers.

“It’s a nice sign for our parishioners, having our back,” she said. She is a member of the Apostles of the Sacred Heart of Jesus congregation.

Bishop Vann recalled how at a parish where he was installing a pastor one of the readings was in Spanish. Someone in the congregation said aloud the readings needed to be in English. The man was booed and the new pastor began to speak in German to show his immigrant roots, said the bishop.

Esther Valdes, a San Diego immigration attorney, said she wants to empower the law-abiding immigrants, not the 7 percent of undocumented with criminal backgrounds. A Trump supporter, Valdes believes the administration is enforcing the law.

As an attorney, Valdes said she is “pro-immigrant and pro-law.” Her practice is “focused on due process that every human being is entitled to,” she said. She has organized workshops for parents who are unauthorized immigrants to have the key documents for their school-age American children if they are deported.

In a workshop titled “Answering Fear With Faith and Facts,” advocates urged the audience to recall the story of America.

Immigrants and refugees are “part of our DNA as a country,” said Donald Kerwin, of the Center for Migration Studies of New York.

Pope Francis and the Gospel are the counter arguments to those who would exclude people, he said. While the politicians talk about immigrants as “unworthy of attention, a rival, someone who should be bent to our will,” the pope describes migrants as “a gift, a source of revitalization,” people who open “vistas for a new humanity,” said Kerwin.

Another speaker said advocates cannot lose focus but must pursue policies based on facts and make inroads with people who see immigrants as risks.

“How are we going to play offense? Immigrants are part and parcel of the American experience. We need to find new allies and new messengers. Let’s step up because the game has changed,” said Tom Wong, a political science associate professor at the University of California at San Diego.

He studied government information on “sanctuary” counties, based on ICE criteria, and found these sanctuary counties have lower rates of crime than non-sanctuary counties, he said.